TRCEvidence ArchiveTruth & Reconciliation Commission
← Case register
Amnesty caseHearing and decisionGranted / refused

AM1584/96

2 hearing(s); 1 decision(s); 3 linked source record(s)

What the linked records say

For AM1584/96, the hearing material and the decision need to be read together: the first records the applicants’ evidence, while the second records the Committee’s result. The linked material names Sibongiseni Philani Khumalo, S P Khumalo, Jabulani Wiseman Mzimela and Madala Zamakuhle Mnyandu.

At the hearing, Sibongiseni Philani Khumalo applied to have three individuals cited as applicants rather than implicated parties, arguing they had filed timeous amnesty applications in 1996 for incidents including the Reservoir Hills killings. While Mr Harkoo opposed granting amnesty due to lack of formal application and failure to prove political motivation, Ms Mohammed presented correspondence showing TRC initially treated these persons as applicants before reclassifying them.

TRC members recorded in the transcript include Chairperson, Judge Potgieter; other named questioners or representatives include Ms Mohammed, Mr Harkoo, Mr Panday, Ms Thabethe, Ms Mohammed Addresses, Mr Harkoo Addresses, Mr Panday Addresses, Adv Sandi, Ms Thabethe Addresses, Ms Patel, Mr Webster; the named applicant speakers include Mr Khumalo.

The questioning returned to the route, place and sequence of events, the claimed political purpose and organisational affiliation and what the applicant personally knew and recalled.

In the written decision, an application by three individuals seeking amnesty in Cape Town regarding violence in KwaZulu Natal, including Simi Nzuza's murder and a robbery at Reservoir Hills. The Committee heard evidence from Sibongiseni Philani Khumalo on specific incidents but refused his request for amnesty.

Drafted from the linked source documents and checked automatically before publication (checks: passed). A reading aid, not a finding of the Commission.

Hearing transcripts (2)

Amnesty decisions (1)