TRCEvidence ArchiveTruth & Reconciliation Commission
← Case register
Amnesty caseHearing and decisionMixed

AM2773/96

1 hearing(s); 8 decision(s); 9 linked source record(s)

What the linked records say

This case file, AM2773/96, brings together testimony from the amnesty process and the written decision on the same registered case number. The exact case-number link sits within a wider group of applications. The names and individual outcomes in that group need source-level checking before they are presented as belonging to this case alone.

The hearing records describe the matter as Abduction, assault and murder of justice mandla mbizana; Crimes committed by them in relation to the kidnapping, assault and murder of Justice Mbizana (the Deceased), also known as MK Mandla; Crimes committed by them in relation to the abduction, assault and killing of Petrus Lubane also known as Comrade X (the Deceased) and the destruction of his body by the use of explosives. The case number appears in more than one linked source, so the account keeps the related applications and decisions together.

At the hearing, Amnesty hearing of Brigadier Jan Hatting Cronje regarding the abduction, assault and murder of Justice Mandla Mbizana. Mr du Plessis questioned whether Cronje knew about the specific camp where Mbizana was detained or if he authorised an order for disposal after learning that Crafford had assaulted him during interrogation at Compol. The transcript reveals discrepancies between Prinsloo's evidence on when elimination orders were given and Cronje's testimony that he foresaw death but did not care who killed it, while also noting the conflicting accounts of whether Goosen and Momberg knew about the assault before executing Mbizana.

TRC members recorded in the transcript include Chairperson; other named questioners or representatives include Mr Du Plessis, Mr Malan, Adv Motata, Mr Botha, Mr Jansen, Adv Prinsloo, Mr Joubert, Ms Van Der Walt, Mr Van Heerden, Mr Steenkamp, Adv Prinsloo In Reply, Mr Alberts; the named applicant speakers include Mr Cronje.

The questioning returned to the route, place and sequence of events, the harm to the victims and the applicant’s account of it and the claimed political purpose and organisational affiliation.

In the written decision, amnesty applications by nine applicants regarding the kidnapping, assault, and murder of Justice Mbizana in Hammanskraal. The Truth Commission found it more probable than not that the first applicant killed the activist after learning he possessed intelligence on police targets to prevent him from revealing information abroad.

Drafted from the linked source documents and checked automatically before publication (checks: passed). A reading aid, not a finding of the Commission.

Hearing transcripts (1)

Amnesty decisions (8)

Matter as recorded

  • Abduction, assault and murder of justice mandla mbizana
  • Crimes committed by them in relation to the kidnapping, assault and murder of Justice Mbizana (the Deceased), also known as MK Mandla
  • Crimes committed by them in relation to the abduction, assault and killing of Petrus Lubane also known as Comrade X (the Deceased) and the destruction of his body by the use of explosives
  • Contravening Sections 3, 4, 5, 6, 9 and 29 of the Explosives Act, 26 of 1956