TRCEvidence ArchiveTruth & Reconciliation Commission
← Case register
Amnesty caseHearing and decisionMixed

AM3480/96

2 hearing(s); 3 decision(s); 5 linked source record(s)

What the linked records say

For AM3480/96, the hearing material and the decision need to be read together: the first records the applicants’ evidence, while the second records the Committee’s result. The linked material names Gilbert Ngobese, Bongani Gilbert Ngobese, Sibusiso Mhlongo, Orient Khambule, Philani Luthuli and Lucky Christopher Mnembe.

The hearing records describe the matter as Killing of thulani mthembu; Destruction of property of dingidawo xulu : attempted murder of dingidawo xulu: muntu elias khuzwayo; The murder of Mr Thulani Mzikayifani Mthembu on 26 December 1991 at Cottonlands in the district of Inanda. The case number appears in more than one linked source, so the account keeps the related applications and decisions together.

At the hearing, Gilbert Ngobese submitted an application for amnesty regarding the killing of Thulani Mthembu in Cottonland, claiming he ordered the execution after receiving reports that negotiations with ANC members had failed. He stated his aim was to kill the deceased but expressed remorse while in prison and promised employment if granted forgiveness.

TRC members recorded in the transcript include Chairperson; other named questioners or representatives include Ms Patel, Ms Gabriel, Adv De Jager, Adv Sigodi, Mr Sibanyoni, Mr Mgenge, Mr Mhlongo, Mr Khambule, Mr Luthuli, Mr Mnembe, Ms Mtanga, Adv Bosman, Adv Sandi, Mr Khuzwayo, Ms Mtanga Addresses, Mr Konke; the named applicant speakers include Mr Ngobese.

The questioning returned to the route, place and sequence of events, the claimed political purpose and organisational affiliation and the harm to the victims and the applicant’s account of it.

In the written decision, the TRC refused amnesty for Bongani Gilbert Ngobese regarding the January 1990 attack on Dingidawo Xulu's house in Mahlabathini, Cottonlands. Although he claimed political motives to prevent revenge killings of UDF supporters, the Committee found his actions disproportionate and not associated with a valid political objective under Section 20(3) of the Promotion of Truth and Reconciliation Act.

Drafted from the linked source documents and checked automatically before publication (checks: passed). A reading aid, not a finding of the Commission.

Hearing transcripts (2)

Amnesty decisions (3)

Matter as recorded

  • Killing of thulani mthembu
  • Destruction of property of dingidawo xulu : attempted murder of dingidawo xulu: muntu elias khuzwayo
  • The murder of Mr Thulani Mzikayifani Mthembu on 26 December 1991 at Cottonlands in the district of Inanda