AM3610/96
3 hearing(s); 2 decision(s); 5 linked source record(s)
What the linked records say
The linked sources for AM3610/96 show the path from an amnesty hearing to the Committee’s decision. The linked material names Pumelele Gumengu, Pumulelo Gumengu, Aaron Tyana, Aron Tyani, Sydwell Mzwamadoda Ntisana, Zandisile Edwin Bongweni, Hlumelo Ndzwanenkulu Mxutu, Thomas Mazizi Ntisana and Fundekile Blackie Nombanga.
The hearing records describe the matter as Craig duli coup; Murder of sthembele zokwe; POSTPONEMENT. The case number appears in more than one linked source, so the account keeps the related applications and decisions together.
At Umtata City Hall on Monday the 31st of January 2000, Pumelele Gumengu testified before the Amnesty Committee regarding his application for amnesty concerning involvement in the Craig Duli coup. He stated he acted as a police employee serving orders from superiors and claimed no personal intent to break law despite being arrested with others who faced serious charges.
TRC members recorded in the transcript include Chairperson, Judge Miller; other named questioners or representatives include Mr Malan, Ms Dambuza, Mr Nodada, Mr Mapoma, Mr Sibanyoni, Mr Mnqandi, Ms Patel, Mr Vabaza; the named applicant speakers include Mr Gumengu.
The questioning returned to the claimed political purpose and organisational affiliation, the route, place and sequence of events, the harm to the victims and the applicant’s account of it and what the applicant personally knew and recalled.
In the written decision, the TRC refused amnesty applications by Pumelele Gumengu and Aron Tyani regarding two incidents involving Sithembele Zokwe in Umtata and Butterworth. The Commission rejected the claims because applicants' testimonies were contradictory, improbable, or directly contradicted evidence from former police officer Vulindlela Christopher Shologu.
Drafted from the linked source documents and checked automatically before publication (checks: passed). A reading aid, not a finding of the Commission.
Hearing transcripts (3)
- Hearing transcriptAmnesty hearings: Pumelele Gumengu — craig duli coupCraig duli coupTRC-SABC-000600linked by hearing case number
- Hearing transcriptAmnesty hearings: Pumelele Gumengu — murder of sthembele zokweMurder of sthembele zokweTRC-SABC-000608linked by hearing case number
- Hearing transcriptAmnesty hearings: Pumulelo Gumengu & Aaron Tyana — postponementTRC-SABC-002525linked by hearing case number
Amnesty decisions (2)
- Amnesty decisionRefusedAmnesty decisions: Pumelele Gumengu; Aron Tyani — AM3610/96; AM3786/96The attempted murder of Sithembele Zokwe ("the deceased") at or near the Transkeian Quarry at Ngolo Administrative Area, Umtata on 8 August 1987 and the eventual murder of the deceased at Cegcuwana Administrative Area, Butterworth on 11 January 1988TRC-SABC-004500linked by decision case number
- Amnesty decisionGranted / refusedAmnesty decisions: Sydwell Mzwamadoda Ntisana; Zandisile Edwin Bongweni; Hlumelo Ndzwanenkulu Mxutu; Pumelele Gumengu; Thomas Mazizi Ntisana; Fundekile Blackie Nombanga — AM6359/97; AM6360/97; AM6363/97; AM3610/96; AM6361/97; AM6364/97Conspiracy to commit treason committed by him during or about January 1990TRC-SABC-004729linked by decision case number
Matter as recorded
- Craig duli coup
- Murder of sthembele zokwe
- The attempted murder of Sithembele Zokwe ("the deceased") at or near the Transkeian Quarry at Ngolo Administrative Area, Umtata on 8 August 1987 and the eventual murder of the deceased at Cegcuwana Administrative Area, Butterworth on 11 January 1988
- Conspiracy to commit treason committed by him during or about January 1990