TRCEvidence ArchiveTruth & Reconciliation Commission
← Case register
Amnesty caseHearing and decisionGranted / refused

AM3732/96

1 hearing(s); 1 decision(s); 2 linked source record(s)

What the linked records say

The linked sources for AM3732/96 show the path from an amnesty hearing to the Committee’s decision. The linked material names Phumula Josias Managa, Azwifarwi Carlson Netshivale, Takalani Joseph Nesamari, Mutheiwana Gabriel Ramushwana, Phumula Josias Manga and Muthuphei Ledwick Ramamligela.

The hearing records describe the matter as Defeating the ends of justice and perjury committed in the course of civil litigation which flowed from the incidents of torture. The decision record deals with more than one named applicant.

At the hearing, An amnesty hearing in Tzaneen on 5 May 1999 where Phumula Josias Managa admitted assaulting detainees including Reverend Farisani using electrical shocks and a broomstick, while denying specific acts against others like Mr Mahamba. Judge Khampepe challenged his inconsistent statements regarding Mr Chikororo made in earlier affidavits compared to current testimony.

TRC members recorded in the transcript include Chairperson, Judge Khampepe; other named questioners or representatives include Mr Meyer, Adv Bosman, Mr Van Rensburg, Ms Mtanga; the named applicant speakers include Mr Managa.

The questioning returned to the claimed political purpose and organisational affiliation, what the applicant personally knew and recalled and the route, place and sequence of events.

The written decision records that Five former Venda Security Branch members applying for amnesty regarding torture and perjury following an attack on Sibasa police station in October 1981. The Committee found that four applicants met the Act's requirements but refused Takalani Joseph Nesamari, Phumula Josias Managa, Muthuphei Ledwick Ramaligela, and Mutheiwana Gabriel Ramushwana for failing to fully disclose all relevant facts or because their requests amounted to general amnesty.

Drafted from the linked source documents and checked automatically before publication (checks: passed). A reading aid, not a finding of the Commission.

Hearing transcripts (1)

Amnesty decisions (1)

Matter as recorded

  • Defeating the ends of justice and perjury committed in the course of civil litigation which flowed from the incidents of torture