TRCEvidence ArchiveTruth & Reconciliation Commission
← Case register
Amnesty caseHearing and decisionRefused

AM3786/96

1 hearing(s); 1 decision(s); 2 linked source record(s)

What the linked records say

This case file, AM3786/96, brings together testimony from the amnesty process and the written decision on the same registered case number. The linked material names Pumulelo Gumengu, Aaron Tyana, Pumelele Gumengu and Aron Tyani.

The hearing records describe the matter as POSTPONEMENT; The attempted murder of Sithembele Zokwe ("the deceased") at or near the Transkeian Quarry at Ngolo Administrative Area, Umtata on 8 August 1987 and the eventual murder of the deceased at Cegcuwana Administrative Area, Butterworth on 11 January 1988. The decision record deals with more than one named applicant.

At the hearing, The Amnesty Committee postponed two applications regarding Pumulelo Gumengu and Aaron Tyana because legal representatives lacked time due to late notice, a tornado disrupting communications, missing documentation, and uncompleted investigations from June 1998.

TRC members recorded in the transcript include Chairperson; other named questioners or representatives include Ms Patel, Mr Malan, Mr Vabaza.

The questioning returned to what the applicant personally knew and recalled.

In the written decision, the TRC refused amnesty applications by Pumelele Gumengu and Aron Tyani regarding two incidents involving Sithembele Zokwe in Umtata and Butterworth. The Commission rejected the claims because applicants' testimonies were contradictory, improbable, or directly contradicted evidence from former police officer Vulindlela Christopher Shologu.

Drafted from the linked source documents and checked automatically before publication (checks: passed). A reading aid, not a finding of the Commission.

Hearing transcripts (1)

Amnesty decisions (1)

Matter as recorded

  • The attempted murder of Sithembele Zokwe ("the deceased") at or near the Transkeian Quarry at Ngolo Administrative Area, Umtata on 8 August 1987 and the eventual murder of the deceased at Cegcuwana Administrative Area, Butterworth on 11 January 1988