TRCEvidence ArchiveTruth & Reconciliation Commission
← Case register
Amnesty caseHearing and decisionMixed

AM4396/96

9 hearing(s); 16 decision(s); 25 linked source record(s)

What the linked records say

For AM4396/96, the hearing material and the decision need to be read together: the first records the applicants’ evidence, while the second records the Committee’s result. The exact case-number link sits within a wider group of applications. The names and individual outcomes in that group need source-level checking before they are presented as belonging to this case alone.

The hearing records describe the matter as JOE PILLAY; Murder of 2 ANC terrorists; The killing of two Pan Africanist Congress ("PAC") operatives during or about 1981 - 1982 by members of the security branch of the then South African Police. The case number appears in more than one linked source, so the account keeps the related applications and decisions together.

At the hearing, W.F. Schoon applied for amnesty regarding an incident where three COSAS members were killed near Krugersdorp to prevent their arrest, which he claimed would expose intelligence on Mfalapitsa and endanger his family's life. He stated Brigadier Jan du Preez authorised the plan while Col J.C. Coetzee executed it using explosives at a pump house after Mfalapitsa pretended to train the victims.

TRC members recorded in the transcript include Chairperson, Judge Khampepe; other named questioners or representatives include Mr Visser, Adv De Jager, Ms Van Der Walt, Mr Jansen, Mr Tshabalala, Mr Tshablala, Ms Thabethe, Adv Gcabashe, Mr Levine, Mr Berger, Mr Bizos, Mr Wagener, Mr Du Plessis, Mr Cornelius, Ms Patel, Mr Sibanyoni, Mr Koopedi, Mr Malan, Adv Steenkamp, Ms Makhubele, Mr Hugo, Adv Sigodi, Adv Bosman, Mr Prinsloo, Mr Nel, Mr Lamey, Mr Makondo, Adv Sandi, Mr Hattingh, Mr Toweel, Mr Joubert, Mr Patel; the named applicant speakers include Mr Schoon.

The questioning returned to the route, place and sequence of events, the claimed political purpose and organisational affiliation, what the applicant personally knew and recalled, the harm to the victims and the applicant’s account of it and the use of firearms and who was present when violence occurred.

In the written decision, the TRC Special Report grants amnesty to Lieutenant-Colonel Dirk Kotze Genis and Major Willem Frederick Schoon regarding their involvement in detaining ANC operative Herbert Mbali in November 1972. Both applicants, serving within the security branch at Bloemfontein and Pretoria respectively, were ordered by superior officers to arrest Mbali after his escape from South Africa to Lesotho. The Commission found the incident directly associated with political objectives under Section 18 of the Promotion of National Unity and Reconciliation Act.

Drafted from the linked source documents and checked automatically before publication (checks: passed). A reading aid, not a finding of the Commission.

Hearing transcripts (9)

Amnesty decisions (16)

Matter as recorded

  • Murder of 2 ANC terrorists
  • The killing of two Pan Africanist Congress ("PAC") operatives during or about 1981 - 1982 by members of the security branch of the then South African Police
  • The killing of two unknown African National Congress ("ANC") freedom fighters during or about 1972 at or near Zeerust
  • The killing of Eustice "Bimbo" Madikela, Ntshingo Mataboge (referred to as "Matubane" in the application forms) and Fanyana Nhlapo (collectively referred to as "the deceased") and the attempted killing of Zandisile Musi ("Musi") in an explosion at Krugersdorp on or about 15 February 1982 ("the incident")