AM4458/96
1 hearing(s); 1 decision(s); 2 linked source record(s)
What the linked records say
Vakele Archibald Mkosana, a former Ciskei Defence Force field commander, applied for amnesty for his part in the Bisho Massacre of 7 September 1992. The application concerned the killing of 28 people and the injury of many others after CDF troops opened fire on Alliance marchers who had entered Ciskei for a protest against Brigadier Oupa Gqozo's administration. Mkosana said that a group leaving the Bisho Stadium moved towards the CDF position at Jongilanga Crescent, that he believed shots had come from the crowd, and that Colonel Van der Bank told him to shoot back if they were being fired on. He said he then instructed Major Mbene to use minimum force fire.
At the Bisho amnesty hearing on 3 February 2000, Acting Judge Denzil Potgieter chaired the panel with Advocate N Sandi and Mr J B Sibanyoni. Peet du Plessis represented Mkosana; Michael Smith represented victims; Brian Koopedi represented the ANC; and Mr Mapoma led evidence for the Commission. The panel refused a postponement sought for co-applicant Mzamil(e) Thomas Gonya after hearing that many victims and interested parties had travelled to attend. Alternative representation was arranged for Gonya, while Mkosana's evidence proceeded.
In questioning, Mkosana accepted that he had not seen a marcher fire a weapon, that no soldiers in his immediate position were wounded, and that he had assumed the crowd was shooting at them. He maintained that his instruction was limited to the Jongilanga Crescent troops and denied ordering Gonya to fire a grenade launcher. He accepted that force used was excessive and expressed regret.
The Amnesty Committee found that the marchers were unarmed and that there was no evidence that they had fired on the CDF. It rejected Mkosana's account of shots from the crowd as false and exaggerated. The Committee found the use of general, indiscriminate lethal force against a peaceful march unjustified and disproportionate, including if some marchers had breached permit conditions by leaving the stadium. It was not satisfied that Mkosana's conduct was associated with a political objective as required by the Act, and refused his amnesty application.
The decision also separately considered Gonya's AM 7882/97 application. It found his firing of a rocket launcher in the circumstances inexcusable and refused amnesty to him as well.
Drafted from the linked source documents and checked automatically before publication (checks: passed). A reading aid, not a finding of the Commission.