TRCEvidence ArchiveTruth & Reconciliation Commission
← Case register
Amnesty caseHearing and decisionGranted

AM4494/96

1 hearing(s); 1 decision(s); 2 linked source record(s)

What the linked records say

Nkosinathi Ngwenya and Nicholas Dobo Ntanzi applied for amnesty for the murder of Thulani Ntanzi at Ezindophi, near Eshowe, on 25 September 1993. They said they were members of the IFP Youth Committee, with Ntanzi serving as assistant youth leader. The deceased was Ntanzi’s brother. In the period of political violence before the 1994 election, the applicants described the area as shifting from an IFP stronghold to a mixed area. They believed that killings of IFP members were linked to the ANC and suspected the deceased because he was said to support the ANC and to receive unknown visitors.

At the hearing, Ngwenya admitted firing the fatal shot. He said that an IFP gathering at Luthuli’s house discussed the deceased and agreed that he should be killed. Ngwenya testified that Ntanzi had supplied the information about his brother’s ANC affiliation and visitors, and had asked for help to have him shot. Ngwenya, Ntanzi and Mfana Neyao went to the deceased’s home; Ntanzi knocked, the deceased opened the door, and Ngwenya shot him. Under questioning by Mr Mapoma, Ngwenya added that other people may have followed behind and named Nzameleni, Mhakauwe and Moosa as people present at the earlier discussion, though he could not clearly account for their roles. Mr Lax and Advocate Sigodi questioned the limited basis for Ngwenya’s information and the unusual request to kill a brother. Ngwenya said he had relied on Ntanzi, had not personally seen the alleged visitors clearly, and had been traumatised after his home was burnt and relatives were killed.

The Amnesty Committee accepted that there were inconsistencies and contradictions in the applicants’ evidence, but found that these did not invalidate their applications. It found political motivation, full disclosure and compliance with the Act. Amnesty was granted separately to Nicholas Dobo Ntanzi and Nkosinathi Ngwenya for the murder of Thulani Ntanzi. The deceased’s mother, Thuleni, was referred to the Reparations and Rehabilitation Committee.

Drafted from the linked source documents and checked automatically before publication (checks: passed). A reading aid, not a finding of the Commission.

Hearing transcripts (1)

Amnesty decisions (1)