TRCEvidence ArchiveTruth & Reconciliation Commission
← Case register
Amnesty caseHearing and decisionRefused

AM4505/96

2 hearing(s); 1 decision(s); 3 linked source record(s)

What the linked records say

Francis Dikisi Meyiwa applied for amnesty for the murder of Victor Lembede at Lembede's shop in Ngonyameni Reserve, KwaZulu-Natal, on 21 June 1991. He had been convicted of murder and attempted robbery and was serving 15 years' imprisonment. Meyiwa said that he had joined the South African Communist Party in 1989 and served on a local Peace Committee. He supported the account of the other applicants that they acted on instructions after Ernest Sipho Mahlane, also called Mbambo, allegedly reported that Lembede supported the IFP and supplied it with weapons. Meyiwa said they believed the information and did not investigate it because they regarded the instruction as coming through trusted senior figures.

At the Pinetown hearing, Meyiwa confirmed that he and Joseph Mkhize stayed outside the shop while others entered. He said Mbambo identified Lembede and returned to the vehicle before Nkosinathi Nyawuza and Filbert Ndimande went back into the shop. He maintained that the attack was political and denied that it was planned as a robbery. He accepted that his written account omitted parts of this sequence, saying the omission was a mistake in the statement. The Chairperson, Judge Potgieter and Advocate Sandi questioned the missing detail and the basis for acting on unverified information. Evidence leader Ms Thabethe confirmed that Mthambo, whom Meyiwa said gave instructions, was deceased.

Lembede's sons, Marcus and Sibusiso, said their father was a school principal and shopkeeper, not an IFP member or arms supplier. They described him as diabetic, with impaired mobility, and said the family generally knew where he was. His grandson, Edgar Mukungo, who was present in the shop, testified that he saw Ndimande struggling with Lembede over a firearm. Mukungo said that after he disarmed Ndimande and heard shots, he saw his grandfather fall. He heard Ndimande call for others to get the money and fired towards the attackers, after which they fled. Mahlane denied telling the applicants that Lembede supplied weapons to the IFP. He said they had sought information about Ngonyameni shops because they intended to rob Lembede's shop, and that he accompanied them under duress to show the route and shop.

The Amnesty Committee found Mukungo and Mahlane to be credible and rejected the applicants' political-assassination account where it conflicted with their evidence. It found that Lembede was killed during an abortive planned robbery of his shop, not in an act associated with a political objective. The Committee also found that the applicants had not made full disclosure of relevant facts. Judge A Wilson, Judge D Potgieter and Advocate N Sandi refused Meyiwa's application, together with the other applications dealt with in the shared decision.

An earlier Pinetown hearing record noted that a prior refusal in Meyiwa's matter had not been signed by a judge and was therefore regarded as having no substance, subject to legal advice. The later hearing proceeded and the final signed decision refused amnesty.

Drafted from the linked source documents and checked automatically before publication (checks: passed). A reading aid, not a finding of the Commission.

Hearing transcripts (2)

Amnesty decisions (1)