TRCEvidence ArchiveTruth & Reconciliation Commission
← Case register
Amnesty caseHearing and decisionGranted

AM5901/97

1 hearing(s); 1 decision(s); 2 linked source record(s)

What the linked records say

Stanley Michael Tshoane testified at the Bloemfontein amnesty hearing about the 3 July 1993 attack on the Wesselsbron Sentra Hyperserve supermarket. He confirmed that he owned and drove the vehicle used in the operation and said he was unarmed. He said he travelled from Welkom with Ngesi, Zuko and Sibanda after Khotle instructed them to meet Bhani in Wesselsbron. According to Tshoane, Bhani briefed the group after making reconnaissance, instructed Ngesi and Zuko to enter and shoot, and assigned Sibanda to watch the door for interference. Tshoane said he drove the group to the supermarket, waited outside while the others entered, and then drove them to the location after they returned. He said the weapons were left in Wesselsbron.

Questions at the hearing tested Tshoane's understanding of the purpose of the operation, the claimed AWB connection, and the taking of money. He accepted Khotle's evidence that the order included killing anything alive in the store, but said his own instruction was to drive. When questioned by Mr Steenkamp and Committee members about statements in his application that the owner was the local AWB chairperson and that the supermarket was frequented by AWB members, Tshoane said Khotle had told him this after investigations of people who visited the supermarket. He initially denied knowing money had been taken, then gave changing answers about whether taking money formed part of the mission. He also alleged that a police statement had been made under assault and pressure, while accepting parts of its factual account. The Committee questioned these inconsistencies, including his account of whether he had given evidence at his criminal trial.

The decision considered Tshoane together with Bhani, Ngesi, Khotle, Morrison and Mazete. It recorded that cash and cheques worth about R9,000 were taken, five people were killed and four were wounded. It found that Tshoane had driven Ngesi, Sebenzile and Sibanda to Wesselsbron to meet Bhani, remained in the car during the shooting, and later left for Welkom with Sibanda. Although the Committee found contradictions and inconsistencies in the applicants' evidence and said they had not been fully candid on peripheral matters, it held that the material facts, motive and events at the supermarket had been sufficiently disclosed. It accepted that the attack formed part of PAC/APLA policy during the period described as the year of the Great Storm, found that it had a political objective, and granted Tshoane amnesty for all offences or delicts arising from or incidental to the attack. The families of the deceased and the injured victims named in the decision were referred to the Reparations and Rehabilitation Committee.

Drafted from the linked source documents and checked automatically before publication (checks: passed). A reading aid, not a finding of the Commission.

Hearing transcripts (1)

Amnesty decisions (1)

Matter as recorded

  • Wesselsbron supermarket attack
  • An attack on the Sentra Hyperserve Wesselbron Supermarket