AM8018/97
2 hearing(s); 1 decision(s); 3 linked source record(s)
What the linked records say
The amnesty application of Solomon Collen Mtambo was registered as AM8018/97 in connection with the matter named in the application.
Solomon Collen Mtambo testified before the TRC Amnesty Committee on 3 February 1999 regarding his killing of Mshenga Phumayo on 2 April 1994. He claimed he acted as Chairman of the IFP Youth Brigade to intimidate ANC members and gain support, though cross-examination revealed contradictions about whether a specific person was targeted or if any ANC member could be killed
During an amnesty hearing in Nelspruit on February 3, 1999, the Committee heard arguments regarding Solomon Collen Mtambo's application to grant him amnesty for killing a deceased IFP Youth League Chairman. Legal representatives argued that while political conflict existed between the ANC and IFP parties prior to the incident, there was insufficient evidence of strong political motive or credible self-defence justification given inconsistencies in Mr Mtambo's testimony
The transcript shows the Chairperson, Mr Claassen, Mr Lax, Adv Bosman, Ms Thabete, Mr Phumayo, and Trevor Phumayo taking part in the hearing.
The examination addressed the victims and the applicant’s account of the harm, political purpose and organisational affiliation, and what the applicant personally knew or recalled.
The TRC Special Report on Solomon Collen Mtambo's amnesty application details how numerous inconsistencies in his testimony regarding the murder of Mshengu Phungwayo at Kwadela, Davel, revealed lies about political motives and concealment. The Commission found these discrepancies aimed to establish a false political context rather than disclose truthfully, leading to the refusal of his section 20(1) amnesty application on 4 February 1999
The final decision records: In the result we are not satisfied that the applicant has complied with section 20(1) of the Act and accordingly the application is refused..
Drafted from the linked source documents and checked automatically before publication (checks: passed). A reading aid, not a finding of the Commission.